Pdf religious experience reconsidered a building block approach to the study of religion and other special things by taves annoctober 18 2009 hardcover uploaded by alexander pushkin, the idea of religious experience is deeply embedded in the study of religion and religions as it religion and they religions have come to be. Oct 18, 2009 religious experience reconsidered is an erudite, provocative, timely, and significant contribution to the theoretical underpinnings of the discipline of religious studies writ large. William james popularised the concept many religious and mystical traditions see religious. Eastern influences on rome and the papacy from gregory the great to zacharias, a. Mcnamara, the neuroscience of religious experience, religion 411 2011. The first involved mysticaltype characteristics and was predicted in multivariate linear regression models by the spirituality of the participants, operationalized as a spiritual affiliation, motivation, and practice.
Religious experience reconsidered we will dedicate this class to indepth discussion on taves approach to the study of religious experience. Religion vol 40, issue 4, pages 227378 october 2010. What counts as religious experience department of anthropology. Jan 05, 2010 her latest book is religious experience reconsidered. Despite the reconsidered nomenclature, the unusual experiences that taves brings to the readers attention are, of course, the usual suspects, for they still fall within a family resemblance domain familiar to anyone acquainted with the study of those experiences formerly known as religious, those that people sometimes ascribe the special. Ann tavess religious experience reconsidered is a sign of a global apocalypse that will kill us all. Constructing an object of study was published in religious experience reconsidered on page 120. A buildingblock approach to the study of religion and other special things the. In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, many modernizers in the west and elsewhere advanced the idea that. She proposes a new approach, which takes into account the attribution of religious meaning to specific events, using the term specialness. A building block approach to the study of religion and other special things. Religious experience reconsidered the book of doctrines and. In religious experience reconsidered, ann taves develops an erudite overview of the study of religion from multiple disciplinary perspectives, taking into account sociology, history, biology, anthropology, neurology, philosophy, and psychology.
Aug 02, 2017 are religious experiences too private to study. The concept originated in the 19th century, as a defense against the growing rationalism of western society. Religious experience reconsidered a building block approach to the study of religion and other special things pdf are you. An inquiry into the ingblock approach to the study of religion and other spe nonrational factor in the idea of the divine and its rela cial things. Religious experience reconsidered a building block.
My own response will take up the issue that taves suggests is one of her central aims. Religious experience reconsidered was premised on the idea that experience is a site of contested meaning and value for subjects and scholars. Religious experience reconsidered a building, length. First, it sets religious experience up as the epit ome of something unique or sui generis,1 which must be studied using the special methods of the humanities. Religious experience reconsidered download ebook pdf. Click download or read online button to get religious experience reconsidered book now. This book tests the method outlined in that book on a particu. Religious experience reconsidered lays out a framework for research into religious phenomena that reclaims experience as a central concept while bridging the divide between religious studies and the sciences. The debate over religious experience in the past few decades has been framed in terms of the relationship between experience and representation. Sociology and anthropology faculty articles sociology and. A buildingblock approach to the study of religion and other special things, ann taves, princeton. While many scholars find that pursuit a natural and necessary one. Navigating land mines with ritual politeness in iran saving face. A critical commentary on religious experience reconsidered, james v.
Religious experience reconsidered is an erudite, provocative, timely, and significant contribution to the theoretical underpinnings of the discipline of religious studies writ large. Experience as site of contested meaning and value, religion 404 2010. Winner of the 2010 distinguished book award, society for the scientific study of religion. Religious experience reconsidered the book of doctrines. Religious experience reconsidered a building block approach. The focus of the book is on experiences deemed religious and, by extension, other things considered special rather than religious experience. Pdf religious experience reconsidered download full pdf. Religious experience reconsidered demonstrates how methods from the sciences can be combined with those from the humanities to advance a naturalistic understanding of the experiences that people deem religious. Purchase instant access pdf download and unlimited online access. A microsociological approach was used to describe the retrospective accounts of their religious experiences, the afterthefact interpretations they constructed, how they made those experiences meaningful, and the role cultural systems and.
A buildingblock approach to the study of religion and other special things buy used. Ann taves shifts the focus from religious experience, conceived as a fixed and stable thing, to an examination of the processes by. This collection investigates the phenomenon of religious experience in early judaism and early christianity. Critiques of religious experience reconsidered by ann taves have primarily focused on the books tether to a category of specialness, seen by some as its own problematic metaphysical pursuit. With the discursive turn in the humanities, many humanists turned a suspicious gaze on the concept of experience, questioning whether it was possible to speak of experience at all apart from the way it. A building block approach to the study of religion and other. A sociologist rereads niebuhrs christ and culture, james v. Apr 24, 2018 nearly seventyfive percent of the monks interviewed at a cistercian monastery in the southeastern united states reported having had religious experiences. Her latest book is religious experience reconsidered. Religious experience subjectrelated this focuses on why the reliability of the person claiming the religious experience may be doubted such things as dreams, visions and hallucinations are generally regarded as unreliable conflicting claims between different religious experiences there is a common core. Ann taves, religious experience reconsidered, 16165 mon. The problem of religious experience the idea of religious experience is deeply embedded in the study of religion and religions as it religion and they religions have come to be understood in the modern west. A building block approach to the study of religion and other special things 2009.
Pdf religious experience reconsidered download full. Block approach to the study of religion and other special things by ann taves. Religious experience reconsidered download ebook pdf epub. Pdf ann tavess religious experience reconsidered is a. A buildingblock approach to the study of religion and other special things by ann taves, narrated by nikki james, is produced by university press audiobooks. Although the concept of specialness has drawn considerable attention, my goal in writing the book was to update efforts to use attribution theory to bridge between religious studies and the psychology. Religious experience reconsidered demonstrates how methods from the sciences can be combined with those from the humanities to advance a naturalistic understanding of the experiences that people. The personal religious experiences of cistercian monks. In religious experience reconsidered, i argued that we should not focus on religious experience as if it were comprised of a fixed and stable set of experiences but on how people decide on the meaning and significance of their experiences. Religious experience reconsidered a building, author.
A multiplicity of washing rites and a multiplicity of experiences. Stages of the contemplative path master brown university. The essence of religion was once widely thought to be a unique form of experience that could not be explained in neurological, psychological, or sociological terms in recent. A building block approach to the study of religion and other special things princeton. Ann taves department of religious studies university of. Religious experience stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. She is the author of six books, among them religious experience reconsidered.
Recent studies of human thinking, based on language usage, brain function, body. A buildingblock approach to the study of religion and other special things. A religious experience sometimes known as a spiritual experience, sacred experience, or mystical experience is a subjective experience which is interpreted within a religious framework. The essays consider such diverse phenomena as scribal inspiration, possession, illness, ascent, theurgy, and spiritual transformation wrought by reading, and recognize that the texts are reflective of the lived experiences of ancient religious peoples, which they understood to be. The political and religious culture of early tibet.
Her first book was a great analysis of religious experiences from the eighteenth to the early twentieth century fits, trances, and visions. The essentiality of culture in the study of religion and politics the. Wayne proudfoot on the cultural construction of experiences, religious studies. Religious experience reconsidered is a book by ann taves on the study of religious experience. Robert sharf, university of california, berkeley taves offers a clear introduction to important debates and contested issues in the study of religious. A multiplicity of washing rites and a multiplicity of. The audiobook edition of religious experience reconsidered. Religious experience reconsidered princeton university press. Religious experience reconsidered suggests, in places, that it has made the move to recover the human interests and practices and i could add to that the mundane biochemical procedures that are symbolized in language by verbs, but, i fear, it has not done so consistently or as thoroughly as some of us may wish. Name index was published in religious experience reconsidered on page 203. Submissions from 2010 does taves reconsider experience enough. A buildingblock approach to the study of religion and other special things by ann taves religious experience reconsidered. The sui generis and ascriptive models of religious experience. Choice book award 2010 for religious experience reconsidered fellow, center for the advanced study of the behavioral sciences, palo alto, ca, 200809.
The brain hack we will dedicate this class to viewing and discussing a short film that explores. Additional pdf readings will be uploaded to blackboard. Georges bataille and amy hollywood on mysticism, morality. Will your cognitive anchor hold in the storms of culture.
Religious experience reconsidered a building by velvasommers. Epistemological reflexivity in the sociology of religion, james v. Dec 17, 2020 it found evidence of two types of entheogenic experience that may be called spiritual. Metanarratives and sociological perspectives 1022 t. Religious experience reconsidered wiley online library. Pdf ann tavess religious experience reconsidered is a sign.
364 216 839 1615 878 48 1446 1120 298 1474 41 722 355 746 15 1754 840 1701 844 344 307 383 484 633 1066 207 28 388